Myersvision: A Very Portly Christmas: A Christmas Carol (1951)

Now it’s Audre’s turn to dive into 1951’s A Christmas Carol.  She does so with her typical childlike wonder, coupled with her deep appreciation for the source material.  I can also relate to fifteen-year old Audre, spending a lazy, hot day reading a book that takes place in cold weather.

From the sounds of the review, it seems Audre might have watched the colorized version, which is on Amazon Prime as Scrooge, its title in England.  Amazon does have the film under its American title (A Christmas Carol) in black and white for you purists out there.  Unlike Audre, I—ever the cheapskate—did manage to find a free version on YouTube, though now I have to wonder if that’s a pirated version—d’oh!  Swashbuckling is cool, but intellectual property theft is not; that said, I imagine any royalties from this film are going to the ungrateful heirs of whoever produced it.  Still, let your conscience be your guide.

With that, here is Audre’s review of A Christmas Carol:

I have to share a story. It was summer, I was 15, it was hot outside, I was bored to distraction. After getting on my mother’s nerves a couple of times, she told me to go read a book. I haroomphed my way into the living room and started looking at the titles on the book shelf. I chose A Christmas Carol. I only picked it because it was hot and Christmas (used to) means snow and cold. I sat down in the corner of the couch, propped the book on the arm of it, and started to read.

I stayed in that position for the rest of the day, only getting up to eat and doing the chores I couldn’t get out of. What a story! I grew up on Fifties horror movies but I don’t mind telling you, the ghostly parts of the story gave me the creeps – a definite feeling of dis-ease, so to speak. I finished the book. I looked at the cover. Charles Dickens. I’d never heard of him before.

There are probably 25-30 versions of A Christmas Carol – television programs and films – but for me there is only one: 1951’s theater version starring Alastair Sim as Scrooge. Normally, I wouldn’t address the details of the story, thinking that everyone must surely know the gist of it, but this past weekend my younger sister and her daughter hosted a ‘movie day’ for a mid-twenties young woman my niece had gone to college with. It seems that her education was severely limited as no one had ever introduced her to the movie Miracle on 34th Street (1947). I can’t tell you how hard it is for me to imagine that. So – in case you don’t know anything about A Christmas Carol, here it is in a nut shell: a mean and bitter old man is forced to face his life by the agency of three ghosts.

It so much more than that. It is a redemption story. It’s a cautionary tale. It’s a ‘how do you like the person you see in the mirror’ perception story. And Alastair Sim was born to play Ebenezer. With his his long thin face and sharp blue eyes, he’s exactly what I pictured while reading. Sim, as Scrooge, brings a depth to the part that we don’t see much anymore. He starts out at one end of the emotional spectrum and reaches the heights at the other and you never find yourself not believing everything he does and says. He plays Scrooge so well, you can see yourself in Scrooge. The actor never interferes with the character. John Wayne was always John Wayne whether he wore cowboy clothes or military uniforms. The same is not true of Alastair Sim. Sim gets inside Ebenezer and moves as Ebenezer would. You really have to watch this movie in order to appreciate how underplayed and resonating good acting can be.

I, the ‘clip queen’, am telling you right now. If you haven’t seen this movie, do not go to YouTube and look at clips. It will ruin the movie for you and you’ll completely miss the message and the magic. And true repentance. I couldn’t find the full movie on YouTube so I went to Amazon. I have a Prime membership and only paid $1.99 to rent it and watch it, but that may be true even without the membership. Considering the age of the movie, I was a little surprised that they charged for it at all but I don’t mind. The story and the acting are aging well and I don’t mind $1.99 to be reminded of that.

Oh! Forgot to mention: In America, the movie is called A Christmas Carol but in England it was released as Scrooge. Amazon has the title Scrooge. I was a little fearful that it may have some unforseen alterations but it doesn’t. It’s the movie I’ve known and loved most of my life.


10 thoughts on “Myersvision: A Very Portly Christmas: A Christmas Carol (1951)

  1. While I do love the 1951 version with Alastair Sim – even more so because Sim was normally a comedic actor – I preferred the 1999 rendition with Patrick Stewart (Meh. He’s a family friend so… )

    But… my true guilty pleasure is 1988’s Scrooged with Bill Murray 😆

    Liked by 1 person

    • Jonolan – if you promise not to tell anyone … I also enjoyed Bill Murray’s Scrooged. It definitely had it’s moments but in fairness to you, I only watched it once. I would be lying to you if I told you I didn’t think about Scrooged while writing about Scrooge.

      Liked by 2 people

      • Same, Audre—it’s a good film, but I think I have only seen it once, too. I’ll have to rewatch it when I get back home.

        Speaking of, pray for traveling mercies. My brother and I are flying back from Phoenix today. We’re headed to his place in Indianapolis, with a layover in Minnesota—the heart of this “once-in-a-generation” (per the US Weather Service) blizzard! I’ll likely have to delay my return to South Carolina until Christmas Eve, as the roads will be too icy in Indianapolis tomorrow—and that’s IF we make it to Indianapolis today!

        So far, both flights are go, and I am hopeful that these northern airports have the means and the lead-time to get things ready for flights, but we’ll see. We could be spending Christmas Eve eating from vending machines!

        Liked by 1 person

  2. I saw the link on TCW so thought I would have a read as this wonderful film perfectly illustrates the Christmas message wrapped.

    Alistair Sim was a brilliant comic actor and its difficult to see who could have topped his Scrooge performance.

    As you say it is a tale of redemption and repentance all wonderfully captured in approx 80 minutes of screen time.

    The bit where he asks his nephews wife for forgiveness never fails to move me and I watch this every Christmas. It perfectly captures the Christmas spirit.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s