Monday Morning Movie Review: Halloween Kills (2021)

Halloween has come and gone, and we’re now entering the season of thankfulness—and then Christmas!  But I figured I’d squeeze in one more movie review related to the holiday, as my girlfriend and I saw—perhaps, it’s better to say, “endured”—2021’s Halloween Kills.

Halloween Kills is the sequel to 2018’s Halloween, itself a sequel to 1978’s Halloween (here’s a handy chart of all twelve Halloween films, and a diagram showing the different continuities within the bloated series).  Like Halloween II (1981), which starts immediately following the events of the original, Halloween Kills takes place on the same night as the events of Halloween (2018).  Confused yet?

Well, none of that much matters, besides the characters repeatedly mentioning the Michael Myers murders “forty years ago.”  Really, most of the movie is a sad attempt at making a statement about a mob mentality, itself muddled by the fact that the mob—which keeps chanting, “Evil dies tonight!”—is actually right about the necessity to annihilate Michael Myers once and for all.

Needless to say, it’s not a very good movie.  The 2018 Halloween was a great follow-up to the original (even taking into account that horror movie sequels are almost never good, or justified), and explored the theme of complacency in the face of a real existential threat.  Lori Strode’s character correctly understand that there is evil in the world, and Michael Myers is the relentless embodiment of it.  She therefore wisely takes major precautions to protect herself against the inevitable return of the man in the mask.

The second film, however, largely confines Jamie Lee Curtis’s Strode to a hospital bed, where she ineffectually mumbles and shouts about Michael Myers.  Instead, the focus of the film shifts to some of the obscure minor characters from the first movie, including the now-grown children that Strode babysat on that fateful night.  These characters are not particularly compelling or interesting, and the film’s flashbacks to the past don’t do much to make the audience care about them.

While the film had some impressive kills—if you’re into that kind of thing—it was mostly boring.  That’s pretty much the one thing a good horror movie cannot be.  Sure, there were some moments of tension, and given that Michael Myers can seemingly phase in and out and space at will, the viewer can never be sure when he’ll pop out, or if the closet a character is poking into will be empty.  But besides those slow-build jump scares and Michael’s sheer ferocity, there’s not much driving interest.

Granted, I was tired after the Spooktacular, but even so, I caught myself nearly dozing off during the long middle section of the film.  There’s an entire scene in which a mental patient who escaped with Michael is hunted down by an angry mob.  The mob leader—one of the children Strode babysat in 1978—insists that no one knows what Michael really looks like, so the escapee must be Michael.

Never mind that the escapee is wearing his prison jumpsuit, as opposed to the dark blue coveralls that Michael favors.  Never mind that the man is fleeing from people, the one thing Michael never does.  Neither of those points matter, because the movie is trying to make a statement about… something—mob hysteria?  Halloween Kills was filmed in late 2019, but Jamie Lee Curtis has stated retroactively that it’s a statement about the 6 January 2020 protests, as well as Black Lives Matter.  It can’t be the former, as filming was completed by November 2019.  If it’s the latter, and the film is trying to make the point that “mob rule is bad,” that doesn’t seem very flattering to BLM (another related thread in the film is that the system has failed to apprehend and detain Michael Myers, so the people must do so; maybe that fits the BLM ethos more, but the film still is not an endorsement of mob violence).

Regardless, this whole section of the film is asinine and booooring.  It took away from the fun and thrill of a Halloween movie—which are all, at their heart, about a relentless, soulless killing machine—and tried to shoehorn in an incoherent message.

One thing the film seemed to do well was to restore to Michael Myers that faceless, reasonless quality, the very thing that makes him so terrifying—no one knows why he kills, they just know he does.  Even here, the scriptwriters seemed confused about what to do.  At one point, a character mentions that Michael is pure, implacable evil, but another character describes him almost sympathetically as a six-year old in a man’s body with an animal’s mind.  That attempt to psychoanalyze or rationalize Michael’s behavior could be one character grasping at straws, but it felt like the screenwriters trying to explain Michael’s drive to kill.

What made the original 1978 Halloween so effective—as many commentators have noted before me—is that no one knows Michael’s motivation.  Indeed, the events seemed to be set into place because Laurie Strode knocks on the front door of the Myers house and skips away laughing.  Michael just happens to see her, and his night of terror begins.

In essence, the script tries to do way too much with introducing obscure characters that only die-hard Halloween fans will remember well, if at all, and completely muddies the waters of who Michael Myers is.  Laurie Strode is sidelined, and there’s even a whole conversation about Michael not wanting her, but simply wanting to go back home.  Doesn’t that undermine the premise of the last movie entirely?

One amusing note, as a coda:  a gay couple has moved into the old Myers house and fixed it up.  These two men playing house—Big John and Little John—are the quintessential gentrifying gay men:  listening to weird jazzy Halloween records; making a charcuterie board on Halloween; wearing silk robes around the house; and fixing up a distressed property that was abandoned for decades.  To the film’s credit, it treats them like any other of Michael’s victims, rather than giving them a pass to score easy identity politics points.

That aside, Halloween Kills is a muddled, slow, shambling mess.  It’s okay for Michael Myers to be those things, but not his movies.

7 thoughts on “Monday Morning Movie Review: Halloween Kills (2021)

  1. Thanks Tyler.

    Tina says we’ll probably end up watching this but to be honest, I don’t see the point. Michael Myers has been burned alive, shot, stabbed and in H20, he was decapitated. Since the latter, he has come back thrice more. The only way this franchise will end is if they put him in a woodchipper and have done with him but knowing the daft returns, he’ll probably come back from that too! 🙂

    I sent you our Halloween pics, by the way, and had hoped to see your Spooktacular here. Have you already posted on it and I missed it?

    Liked by 1 person

    • Hi Ponty,

      Thanks for the pictures! I see the e-mails but have to pull them up; it’s a very busy Monday morning.

      I have not given the full rundown on the Spooktacular yet; I’ll be posting more details on Saturday. All of most important information will likely be in FRONT of the paywall, though. What I will say here quickly is that it was a fun evening, but turnout was down substantially from last year. I have several theories as to why that was the case, but I think the main reason was that most everyone was celebrating Halloween Saturday instead of Sunday (for all the obvious reasons), so folks had other plans and lots of alternative entertainment options.

      What I found really shocking—and a tad depressing—was that no one at the event bought a single t-shirt! I did quite a few pre-sales, which helped, and a few attendees had already purchased their shirts. But according to Shelby, no one bought a single piece of merch. As such, this year’s Spooktacular ended up costing me a great deal of money.

      On the plus side, I have a fairly complete inventory of shirts that I can sell next year, as I did not put the year on the shirts this year (a mistake I made last year). I also have a good sense of what I need to do differently for next year to bring back the crowds.

      As for the flick, yes, it’s worth seeing for your Halloween Completionist badge, but I was quite disappointed. Shelby and I watched _Halloween 4_ yesterday morning, and we vastly preferred it to _Halloween Kills_.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Sorry to hear of the poor turnout for your Spooktacular. You’re probably right about Halloween Saturday – we had trick or treaters yesterday and not Saturday but we did hear quite a lot of activity the previous night. Some people tend to go in for that ‘not on a school night’ thing so I guess Saturday seemed like the obvious choice.

        As for the t-shirts, I’ll have a look at some point, when my account starts moving up instead of down! 🙂
        Halloween, bonfire night, Christmas, green taxes on our energy bills – it’d be nice to see a monthly bill that makes me smile for a change.

        I don’t think I have a choice in terms of avoiding Halloween Kills – Tina wants to watch it so I’ll have to watch it! I think we’ll be staying away from experimental films for a while though. The House That Jack Built left an odd taste in her mouth and she didn’t even watch the really disturbing bits, like the part with the duckling. I think we’ll stick to safe for a while.

        Liked by 1 person

      • Dude, if you sign up for a subscription to my SubscribeStar page, I’ll get a couple of shirts over to you and Tina. $5 a month (or the equivalent in pounds) would be a bill that would make _me_ happy—ha!

        But, yeah, I hear ya—lots of expenses these days. Fortunately, I was able to churn out enough in private lessons this month that I was able to subsidize my Spooktacular losses. I also have made several t-shirt sales _since_ the event, so that should help to further defray the costs. I’m writing this one off as a very fun learning experience, and a down payment towards future front porch concerts.

        _The House That Jack Built_ was hard for ME to watch at points, and I thought that repeated viewings of horror flicks had inured and desensitized me to feeling such fictionalized revulsion. It was a brilliant film, but, damn.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s