Monday Morning Movie Review: Spider-Man: Brand New Day (2026)

While visiting my older brother the other weekend, we drove down to the AMC in Savannah, Georgia to catch Spider-Man: Brand New Day (2026). I’m of the mind that if there is a Spider-Man movie, I must see it.

I’m not a huge comic book nerd (although I like them; I just don’t know all the deep lore and storylines and such), and I haven’t devoured hundreds of issues of Spider-Man comics, but I’ve always appreciated the character. Plus, my generation came of age with the Tobey Maguire flicks (directed by none other than Sam Raimi). I’ve heard it said that each generation has their Spider-Man; mine is Maguire (and my Mary Jane is Kirsten Dunst). Also, where else are you going to see Willem DaFoe lose his mind as a super villain (and not as just every other character he plays)?

That said, I love the character and his backstory. Spider-Man is basically a goofy kid with amazing powers who has to grow up fast and learn some hard lessons. He is duty-bound—“with great power comes great responsibility”—to protect those around him, even at great personal cost. Very often, Spider-Man doesn’t get the girl; sometimes, the girl gets killed!

That theme continues with the current iteration of Spider-Man as portrayed by the eternally boyish Tom Holland, albeit with a twist that I think Spider-Man: Brand New Day essentially nullifies.

The previous Spider-Man film in this iteration of the webbed crusader, Spider-Man: No Way Home (2021) saw our hero recklessly toying with powerful magic courtesy of Dr. Strange. After his crazy attempt to alter reality went horribly awry (so the movie would have a plot), Spidey made a wish that Mary Jane and his friend Ned would have no memory of Peter Parker. His belief was that doing so would protect MJ and Ned from danger, as their association with Spider-Man/Peter had already put Spidey’s friends into harm’s way multiple times.

The film picks up in the wake of that spell. Spider-Man did not enroll at MIT with his former friends, and instead has spent four years working tirelessly to protect New York City from criminal threats. Thanks to his persistence (and workaholism) crime is way down, and he’s a hero to the people of New York.

Unfortunately, the extreme stress and social isolation are taking their inevitable toll, and the burnout sees Spidey experiencing painful headaches and other ailments. His AI assistance helpfully notes that his arachnid DNA is overriding his human DNA, causing multiple problems: his eyes turn black; he loses basic impulse control; and his synthetic web shooters are incompatible with the organic webs that are suddenly shooting from his wrists.

The timing, naturally, is not good: a new, telepathic threat has appeared, with the ability to leap into people’s minds, causing a granny to drive a tank into a prison run by the hilariously-named “Department of Damage Control,” which is the film’s shadowy government bureaucracy that claims to do good but we all know is probably doing something heinous.

Spidey then sets out to find a scientific solution to his conundrum, consulting with Bruce Banner (the Incredible Hulk). Meanwhile, destiny—or, perhaps, the demands of the plot—see him reuniting with MJ and Ned, who, sadly, have no memory of him. Seeing them again exacerbates his stress and feelings of loneliness, sending his arachnid DNA haywire.

Also, the Punisher shows up, which is pretty fun.

Here’s where I think the events of this film undermine and/or nullify the events of No Way Home: Peter makes this grand sacrifice (only after trying to have his girlfriend-cake and eat it, too) only for MJ and Ned to still find themselves in mortal danger. Indeed, Peter/Spidey finds himself trying to reconnect with them both (with mixed results), albeit somewhat surreptitiously.

Ultimately, the screenwriters can’t or won’t let Spider-Man’s sacrifice stick, because it’s too emotionally satisfying to tease the possibility that he and MJ (played here by Tom Holland’s real-world wife, Zendaya; she actually acts well here, and does more than make her grumpy Muppet face) might get back together—a possibility I am sure will be dragged out over another couple of films.

It’s almost like television writing, the “will they/won’t they” just being dragged out over another decade of movies instead of a three or four season.

That major quibble aside, I enjoyed the film. Like all Marvel flicks, though, I forgot almost everything just a few days after seeing the flick. Indeed, major plot points only started coming back to me as I began writing this review.

But, as I said, I liked the movie. It’s always fun seeing Spider-Man swinging around. The angle of him contending with his arachnid DNA gave it the feel of a superhero origin story flick, where the first third or so is just the hero trying to figure out how to adapt to his abilities. Yes, there’s a lot of scientific-sounding gobbledygook that is essentially magical incantations for plot convenience, but that’s kind of the fun of Spider-Man, too: he’s supposed to be this lanky nerd who developed powers from an accidental spider bite. It’s supposed to be kind of goofy and sci-fi.

Audiences seem to have enjoyed it, too. The flick has currently grossed around $2.451 billion against a budget of $225 million. Figuring a marketing budget of $225 million, that’s a total cost of $550 million, so the film more than broke even. That’s refreshing for superhero movies, which have really struggled over the last few years as the loooooong Marvel Cinematic Universe era essentially ended after Avengers: Endgame (2019). Yes, I know they kept making movies, but other than the flicks about Spidey, which have actually done any numbers?

So, even with audiences suffering from superhero movie fatigue, Spider-Man still does well at the box office. I think it goes back to my opening: the character is relatable. We have all been Peter Parker to some extent—awkward, adolescent, uncertain—and most of us have had some variation of his relationships: the goofy best friend, the weirdly unattainable girl, etc. Tom Holland brings a fun and boyish energy to the role, and Jacob Batalon as Peter’s friend Ned is infectiously excitable (there’s a scene where Spider-Man and Ned build a LEGO set together).

Is it high art? No. Is it particularly memorable? Not quite in the same way those Tobey Maguire films were. Is it fun for a Saturday night and a bucket of popcorn with your brother? Absolutely.