The explosive news Monday was that tech giants Facebook, Spotify, YouTube, and Apple banned Alex Jones and Infowars from their respective platforms. While Jones is a controversial figure who peddles in rumor, conspiracy, and innuendo, the concerted action from separately-owned and -managed Silicon Valley entities is unsettling.
Historian Victor Davis Hanson wrote a piece for National Review arguing that Silicon Valley giants should be regulated—or even busted up—to prevent monopolistic and anti-competitive practices, drawing parallels to the muckraking reformers of the early twentieth century who brought down Standard Oil. I’m wary of such solutions-by-government, but Hanson was anticipating a problem that has become all-too familiar: the massive social and cultural clout the unmoored tech giants wield.
Steven Crowder of online late-night show Louder with Crowder often pokes fun at—and complains loudly about—the various murky “terms and services” and “community guidelines” rules that are ever-shifting in continuously updated apps and platforms. A slight change in a Facebook algorithm—or a Twitter employee having a bad day—can lead to massive reductions in traffic for a YouTuber or blogger. Reduced—or eliminated—traffic means less revenue. YouTubers like Crowder who helped build the platform now find their videos demonetized for the most mysterious of reasons.
Candace Owens was kicked from Twitter because she rewrote recent New York Times hire and anti-white racist Sarah Jeong’s tweets by replacing disparaging uses of “white” with “black” or “Jew.” Razorfirst posted a video some months ago of him literally just talking about nonsense for five minutes… and it was immediately demonetized.
Now Alex Jones is banned across multiple platforms from multiple platforms—which is absolutely chilling. Jones is certainly not without controversy, and I wouldn’t take his ramblings to heart without a heaping helping of salt, but just because he’s a kinda nutty conspiracy kook who enjoys ripping his shirt off doesn’t make his situation any less terrible. If we write off Jones because he was “asking for it” by being kooky, then we’re missing the whole point of free speech.
And, yes, the usual objections are inevitable: “but, TPP, the First Amendment speech protections only apply to the government! Companies can set whatever guidelines they want! You can use some other platform! He still has his website.” Yes, yes, yes, and yes—all true. Nevertheless, the arbitrary power we’ve voluntarily—if unwittingly—yielded to these tech elites is staggering. And this preponderance of power may be where Hanson has a point.
Is not the function of the government to protect the rights of its citizens from threats and violations, both foreign and domestic? In this case, arbitrary bans—particularly these coordinated attacks on controversial figures—seem to be a powerful means of preventing an individual and/or entity from delivering his message in the public square. Like the street corner doomsayer, Alex Jones has a right to be heard, even if he’s sometimes insane (for me, the jury is out on Jones; I enjoy the entertainment value of his commentary, and I think he’s probably right about 80% of the time, but then he veers off into crisis actors, etc.—the danger of a man who is charismatic and convincing).
Today, it’s a relatively buffoonish character like Jones. Tomorrow—who knows? Do we really want to find out? “Hate speech” is a code word for silencing conservatives. It’s better to publish one racist screed from a lonely nut (not referencing Jones here, to be clear) than to muzzle millions because their innocuous, mainstream conservative viewpoint might been interpreted as a “dog-whistle.”
Sunlight is the best disinfectant, and it’s often better to give madmen the rope with which to hang themselves. When we try to silence them, they only gain in credibility (indeed, when I read the news, I immediately went… to Infowars!).
[…] I posted this morning, Alex Jones and InfoWars were unceremoniously deplatformed in a coordinated, cross-corporate […]
LikeLike
[…] shifted back to the fringes, with the real threats to liberty returning to online flame wars and techno-corporate elites deplatforming anyone to the right of Joseph Stalin. Sure, Antifa—the ironically-named organization of […]
LikeLike
[…] This election is a referendum on Trump and Trumpism, yes, but it’s also a series of choices: the Constitution, or lawlessness. Capitalism, or communism. Rule by the people, or rule by an entrenched, technocratic elite. […]
LikeLike
[…] That lust for efficiency drives income inequality, particularly benefiting the technology sector/Silicon Valley […]
LikeLike
[…] Northam non-troversy), to demonize young conservatives, to harass conservatives at dinner, and to denounce anyone who doesn’t believe whatever the latest frontier of social justice is this […]
LikeLike
[…] colors—its penchant for violence, its destruction of the reputation of an innocent man, its dominance of Silicon Valley to deplatform rivals—as the levers of power slip […]
LikeLike
[…] of the Left, but consider the entire entertainment, corporate (especially “Big Tech“), and academic apparatuses that are arrayed in favor of progressivism’s cause du […]
LikeLike
[…] Internet was a bastion of freedom for conservatives and dissidents of all stripes. Now the tech giants are clamping down on the Right, and even the heretofore apolitical. Remember: merely being apolitical is, to the totalitarian […]
LikeLike
[…] that exists in the federal government. Indeed, it’s an unholy alliance of D.C. insiders, corporate elites, academic Leftists, and social justice warriors, all arrayed against President Trump and his […]
LikeLike
[…] this week was YouTube’s unceremonious demonetizing of Steven Crowder, yet another example of techno-elites censoring conservative and dissident voices. Apparently, YouTube has somewhat reversed that decision if Crowder removes the hilarious […]
LikeLike
[…] not proof that being gay aligns you with the full power and influence of big corporations and our techno-elites, then there’s no convincing […]
LikeLike
[…] of constant censorship from techno-elites and their ever-shifting “terms of services,” conservative and Dissident Right voices […]
LikeLike
[…] Big Tech companies, the education system, and media have addressed this situation with more, not less, censorship and indoctrination, which now has reached cartoonishly patronizing levels. The most mundane of observations are now grounds for dismissal from one’s job. […]
LikeLike
[…] shifted back to the fringes, with the real threats to liberty returning to online flame wars and techno-corporate elites deplatforming anyone to the right of Joseph Stalin. Sure, Antifa—the ironically-named organization of […]
LikeLike
[…] “Banned! Techno-Elite Deplatform Alex Jones” – this piece chronicled the surreptitious, cross-platform, nearly simultaneous deplatforming of InfoWars, Alex Jones’s alternative news and commentary site. The coordinated nature of Jones’s deplatforming was such a stark example of collusion across multiple companies in the same industry, it practically begged for a Department of Justice investigation. As far as I know, the government never looked into it. Naturally, I immediately purchased a bunch of InfoWars stickers, because now we pretty much have to support Alex Jones, even if he is a bit wacky. […]
LikeLike
[…] the United States, our censorship is of a softer, though no less dangerous, variety: tech companies deplatforming controversial figures and the like. There’s also the suffocating sense of self-censorship, as people are […]
LikeLike
[…] of a recent video from Paul Joseph Watson. PJW raises eyebrows because of his association with InfoWars, but who cares? Alex Jones has been proven right more times than not. Regardless, I’m […]
LikeLike
[…] wrong. Milo is bemoaning the fact that conservatives are routinely deplatformed from social media, eradicating their ability to reach fans and to earn a steady living from their […]
LikeLike
[…] This election is a referendum on Trump and Trumpism, yes, but it’s also a series of choices: the Constitution, or lawlessness. Capitalism, or communism. Rule by the people, or rule by an entrenched, technocratic elite. […]
LikeLike
[…] pressing issue of our time. Anyone reading this blog has surely witnessed the deplatforming of conservative figures under nebulous “community guidelines,” as well as the personal and professional ruin […]
LikeLike
[…] incidences are eerily, distressingly common. Milo, Gavin McInnes, Laura Loomer, Alex Jones—all victims of Big Tech’s insatiable lust for virtue-signalling and social […]
LikeLike
[…] That lust for efficiency drives income inequality, particularly benefiting the technology sector/Silicon Valley […]
LikeLike
[…] also clear that Big Tech is aligned aggressively against Trump (such as Alex Jones’s remarkably coordinated deplatforming). Various companies’ Terms of Service have morphed surreptitiously to ban conservatives on […]
LikeLike
[…] colors—its penchant for violence, its destruction of the reputation of an innocent man, its dominance of Silicon Valley to deplatform rivals—as the levers of power slip […]
LikeLike